Would you take Josh Allen over Carr?
I would. Howitzer arm (could be the biggest arm I've ever seen, live along the lines of Kyle Boller), gunslinger with a ton of mobility. A lot like Brett Favre or John Elway, and yes, he has a LONG way to go to get to that HOF status but he's really young and getting better and better.
I liked what I saw from him last season. He starts getting that confidence up and he could put up a ton of yards. There's no patch of grass on the field that's safe from this fucker's arm, that's for sure.