Everyone knows my preference here. I've watched Smith for a long time now, and I fully believe an NFL FB would blast him right out of the hole like he wasn't even there. And he better fucking hope he never has to play us next season because Lynch would chew him up and spit him out.
Edmunds isn't perfect but he has everything it takes to BECOME perfect. Dude is 20 lbs heavier than Smith and twice as athletic. Smith has sideline-to-sideline speed but can say the exact same thing about Edmunds. Dude is just a monster, and has the kind of make-up speed and athleticism to mitigate any mental errors he might make in his first couple of years.
For fuck's sake the kid's only 19 right now. "The sky is the limit" doesn't even cover this guy.